Lindsay HubbardandCarl Radke’s romance was not something theirSummer HousecostarPaige DeSorbosaw coming.During an appearance onWatch What Happens Liveon Monday, hostAndy Cohenasked Paige, 29, whether she sensed that the twosome were “vibing” at Kyle Cooke andAmanda Batula’sSeptember wedding.“Not at all,” said Paige. “When I first heard it, I was like, ‘Oh, my God.’ But I love it.“Dating rumors between Lindsay, 35, and Carl, 37, began to swirl this past fall after sheposted a photo of the pairat the wedding. Their relationship wasn’tconfirmeduntil January as Lindsay toldPage Sixthey’re “very much together” but weren’t currently using girlfriend/boyfriend labels.While celebratingtheir first Valentine’s Day togetherthe next month, Lindsay said she “honestly didn’t think it was possible to love someone this much.“Lindsay Hubbard/InstagramLindsay laterrecounted how the pair’s romance first flourishedat the cast’s prom-themed party — an event featured in the Bravo hit’s April 25 episode.“So like normal proms … when you and your best friend are both single, you just got to prom together … But the universe had different plans that day,” she wrote on her Instagram Story last month. “@carlradke was so damn handsome … so sweet … so thoughtful. He had me cracking up ALL day. And we truly didn’t leave each other’s side that day. My heart was beating faster, and something just felt different.“Astrid Stawiarz/Bravo/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty ImagesNever miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.Lindsay added that “something just clicked in a different way, at the same time, for both of us at Prom.“At this time, Lindsay hasbegun the process of freezing her eggs. She has had Carl’s support throughout the process — even as she endures mood swings.“I talked to Carl on the phone this morning (because he’s been out of town this wknd) and I teared up,” shewroteon Instagram. “Then laughed hysterically at something, and then cried because my eyes are puffy and I feel like a pirate! 😂

Lindsay HubbardandCarl Radke’s romance was not something theirSummer HousecostarPaige DeSorbosaw coming.

During an appearance onWatch What Happens Liveon Monday, hostAndy Cohenasked Paige, 29, whether she sensed that the twosome were “vibing” at Kyle Cooke andAmanda Batula’sSeptember wedding.

“Not at all,” said Paige. “When I first heard it, I was like, ‘Oh, my God.’ But I love it.”

Dating rumors between Lindsay, 35, and Carl, 37, began to swirl this past fall after sheposted a photo of the pairat the wedding. Their relationship wasn’tconfirmeduntil January as Lindsay toldPage Sixthey’re “very much together” but weren’t currently using girlfriend/boyfriend labels.

While celebratingtheir first Valentine’s Day togetherthe next month, Lindsay said she “honestly didn’t think it was possible to love someone this much.”

Lindsay Hubbard/Instagram

Summer House’s Lindsay Hubbard Reveals ‘Where It All Started’ in Romance with Carl Radke

Lindsay laterrecounted how the pair’s romance first flourishedat the cast’s prom-themed party — an event featured in the Bravo hit’s April 25 episode.

“So like normal proms … when you and your best friend are both single, you just got to prom together … But the universe had different plans that day,” she wrote on her Instagram Story last month. “@carlradke was so damn handsome … so sweet … so thoughtful. He had me cracking up ALL day. And we truly didn’t leave each other’s side that day. My heart was beating faster, and something just felt different.”

Astrid Stawiarz/Bravo/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

Carl Radke and Lindsay Hubbard

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Lindsay added that “something just clicked in a different way, at the same time, for both of us at Prom.”

At this time, Lindsay hasbegun the process of freezing her eggs. She has had Carl’s support throughout the process — even as she endures mood swings.

“I talked to Carl on the phone this morning (because he’s been out of town this wknd) and I teared up,” shewroteon Instagram. “Then laughed hysterically at something, and then cried because my eyes are puffy and I feel like a pirate! 😂

source: people.com